Cliff bought 2 homes with Bitcoin mortgages: Clever… or insane?

Cliff bought 2 homes with Bitcoin mortgages: Clever… or insane?

Imagine securing a dream home today while still riding the wave of Bitcoin's future growth. This innovative approach to real estate allows crypto enthusiasts to leverage their digital assets without selling them, presenting a compelling, albeit risky, alternative to traditional home financing.

The Allure of Leveraging Your Crypto for a Home

For many in the crypto space, the idea of owning a substantial amount of Bitcoin or Ethereum isn't just about financial security; it's about a belief in its transformative power. If you've been fortunate enough to accumulate, say, four to six Bitcoin, or perhaps 111 to 166 ETH, you're looking at a portfolio potentially large enough to buy an average-priced house in places like the US or Australia. But here’s the kicker: who wants to cash out their precious crypto today when market prognosticators are forecasting a tenfold increase in value down the line?

This is where the dream of a Bitcoin-backed mortgage truly shines. It promises a way to get your hands on that coveted property now without having to liquidate your digital gold. The hope is that you'll simply cover the interest payments for a few years, and then, thanks to Bitcoin's projected appreciation, you can pay off the entire mortgage using just a fraction of your original holdings. Pretty neat, right? What's more, these types of loans often boast a quicker and less cumbersome application process than your standard mortgage. Typically, you just need to put up Bitcoin collateral worth about 50% more than the loan amount, and you're good to go. It’s like using your most prized possession as collateral, but with the added potential for that possession to grow significantly in value while it’s doing its job.

The Double-Edged Sword: Risks and Rewards

Now, before we all rush out to secure our next property with crypto, it's crucial to pump the brakes and look at the potential downsides. These innovative financial products aren't without their considerable risks. For starters, the interest rates can sometimes be eye-wateringly high, often double what you'd find with a conventional mortgage. That alone can make a significant difference in your monthly outgoings.

But perhaps the most nerve-wracking aspect for crypto holders is the specter of margin calls. If the price of Bitcoin takes a nosedive and your loan-to-value (LTV) ratio drops below a certain threshold, you could face a margin call. This means your collateral is no longer sufficient to cover the loan, and you'll be asked to add more. If you can't or don't, depending on the specific product or protocol, your Bitcoin collateral could be automatically liquidated. We're talking about either a full sell-off or just enough to bring your LTV back into line. Some lenders might offer a grace period, giving you a window to provide additional collateral, but it's a high-stakes game. Consider this: if you had taken out a Bitcoin-backed mortgage to buy a home in 2021 and didn't beef up your collateral during subsequent market corrections, you might have seen your precious Bitcoin holdings automatically sold off. The volatility of the crypto market, while offering huge upside potential, also presents a very real risk to these types of loans.

Meet Cliff: A Case Study in Crypto-Backed Property

Let's talk about someone who's actually navigated these waters: a 60-year-old construction supply company director named Cliff. He's had quite a journey leveraging his Bitcoin to acquire property. Interestingly, Cliff plunged a significant chunk—between 40% and 50%—of his total wealth into Bitcoin over an 18-month period during the pandemic. He describes falling down the "hard money rabbit hole" on YouTube, which ignited his passion for decentralized finance. Fast forward a bit, and with Bitcoin's value soaring by nearly 1,000% since his initial investments, his portfolio is now what many Australians would playfully call a "shitload."

Cliff's motivation is quite clear. He’s adamant about holding onto his Bitcoin because, as he puts it, "what else are you going to put your money into that gives you a better rate of return?" Yet, he also desired to "take advantage of it and have access to cash flow without selling it." About a year ago, he did just that, borrowing funds from an Australian crypto lender, Block Earner. This enabled him to purchase two properties and even enjoy a well-deserved honeymoon, all by borrowing against the value of his entire Bitcoin portfolio. His goal? To "buy a couple of properties where you can go to, and enjoy some nice places, and Airbnb them out as well." Ultimately, it’s about enhancing his quality of life.

Now, you might wonder if Cliff was worried about his chosen lender, Block Earner, going bust, especially after a slew of crypto lenders like Celsius Network, Voyager Digital, and BlockFi imploded in 2022. Surprisingly, Cliff wasn't overly concerned, largely because he admits he hadn't heard much about those incidents at the time. Block Earner's specific terms require 150% Bitcoin as collateral and offer a 30-day window to add more cash or Bitcoin if the price drops too far, otherwise a portion of the collateral is sold. Cliff openly shared that he went under the LTV ratio on two separate occasions. He observed that Bitcoin's price dipped but then recovered within the 30-day grace period a couple of times. He also made the spontaneous decision to sell a "couple of Bitcoin" at one point, which he now somewhat regrets, but it effectively brought his LTV ratio down to a comfortably low level.

Why Traditional Banks Fall Short for Crypto Holders

One of the driving forces behind the demand for Bitcoin mortgages is a significant disconnect between traditional finance and the crypto world. Most conventional banks, despite crypto portfolios potentially being worth millions, simply ignore them when assessing a borrower's eligibility for a mortgage. Instead, they scrutinize your savings, stocks, and other traditional assets. It's a frustrating reality for many crypto holders who might be asset-rich in digital terms but cash-poor in the eyes of a conservative lender.

James Coombs, Block Earner's chief commercial officer, highlights this issue perfectly. He explains that numerous customers—and even some of his own staff—have gone through the arduous process of trying to secure a mortgage only to find their crypto assets completely disregarded or valued at zero dollars during the asset test. This oversight forces a growing demographic of wealth holders to seek out alternative financing solutions.

However, the landscape is slowly, albeit incrementally, shifting. In Australia, recent developments indicate that a prominent, unnamed major bank has partnered with Monochrome to allow shares of its Bitcoin ETF to be used as marginable collateral for high-value properties, specifically those valued at Australian $5 million (approximately US $3.26 million) or more. Across the Pacific, in the US, mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have begun to acknowledge Bitcoin, but with a caveat. They now consider Bitcoin as part of a borrower's reserves—essentially, funds a borrower could tap into if they lost their job—rather than directly as collateral for the loan itself. So, while it's a step forward, it still doesn't offer the same direct leverage as a Bitcoin-backed mortgage.

Navigating the Landscape of Crypto Mortgage Providers

So, if traditional routes aren't working, what are the options for those looking to leverage their crypto for property?

Centralized Lenders: Convenience with Caveats

A variety of centralized lenders have emerged, including names like SALT, LEDN, Figure, and Nexo. These platforms allow you to borrow against your crypto collateral to finance a home purchase. They typically offer a range of products with differing interest rates and terms, so it's always wise to thoroughly compare your options. Centralized lenders often come with more user-friendly terms and interfaces, making the process feel familiar to those accustomed to traditional banking. However, there's an inherent risk: being centralized, they are vulnerable to the same kinds of operational failures and mismanagement that led to the collapse of several high-profile crypto lenders in 2022. The risk of the platform itself going bust is a constant concern.

Decentralized Options: Smart Contracts and Volatility

On the other side of the spectrum are decentralized lenders such as Aave and Morpho. These protocols operate on the blockchain, governed by smart contracts that execute automatically based on predefined rules. While this immutability eliminates the risk of a centralized entity going bankrupt, it introduces a different set of challenges. The "unflinching" nature of smart contracts means automatic liquidation during sudden market downturns, like the flash crash experienced on October 10th, can be swift and unforgiving. Furthermore, some decentralized protocols might offer funds in their native stablecoins, which, despite being backed by crypto, can still experience minor fluctuations in value. For instance, the Bitcoin-only lender Mezo provides funds in its native stablecoin MUSD, but it has occasionally dipped slightly below its dollar peg, albeit briefly to 98.4 cents in the past month.

Regional Offerings: US and Australia Lead the Way

Both the US and Australia are seeing significant developments in the Bitcoin mortgage space, with dedicated platforms emerging to serve this niche but growing market.

Milo in the United States

In the US, Milo has been a prominent player, rolling out Bitcoin-backed mortgages since 2022 and expanding to Ethereum-backed mortgages in 2023. To date, they’ve facilitated a remarkable $80 million in property purchases for their clients. Milo stands out by offering up to 100% financing for loans as large as $5 million, often without requiring a down payment. When considering all their various financial products, the company reports having originated a total of $250 million in mortgages.

Block Earner Down Under

Meanwhile, in Australia, Block Earner announced its own Bitcoin-backed mortgage product in June, designed to cover loans up to $3.26 million. They are optimistic about seeing homes purchased through this product within the current calendar year. The demand is certainly there: Block Earner has already accumulated a waiting list representing roughly $500 million Australian dollars (or about $326 million USD) in property value. This translates to approximately $65 million in potential loans, with the average mortgage size around $1.04 million. This overwhelming interest has actually pushed their wider launch back to "early 2026" as they work to secure sufficient funding.

In practice, Block Earner's Bitcoin-backed mortgage is structured as a Bitcoin-backed deposit with a higher comparison interest rate, currently sitting around 11.9%. This is then combined with a standard mortgage for the remaining loan amount, secured through one of their "preferred mortgage partners" at a normal variable rate. James Coombs explains that while borrowers can secure up to 60% of their home's value, the most common request on their waiting list is for about 22%. Essentially, it's tailored for individuals who want to put down the crucial 20% deposit but lack the immediate cash. It’s worth noting that in both the US and Australia, if you put down less than a 20% deposit, you’re usually required to take out additional, often costly, insurance—known as private mortgage insurance (PMI) in the US and lender’s mortgage insurance (LMI) in Australia. This insurance protects the lender in case you default, adding another layer of expense to the borrowing process.

Legal Hurdles and Borrower Confidence

Any innovative financial product, especially one dealing with emerging technologies like cryptocurrency, is bound to encounter regulatory scrutiny. Block Earner, for instance, has been in a legal tussle with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), the local equivalent of the SEC. ASIC has appealed to the High Court, seeking to overturn Block Earner’s Federal Court victory regarding its "Earner" product.

However, Block Earner is quick to reassure potential mortgage holders that this ongoing legal battle poses no risk to them. They state that the court case specifically concerns a discontinued product and that "no products Block Earner currently offers are relevant to the case." Furthermore, they confirm their status as an authorized representative of Mortgage Direct, which holds an Australian Credit License, ensuring their current offerings are properly regulated. Dr. Aaron Lane, a senior lecturer in law at Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology University, echoes this sentiment, suggesting it's highly unlikely the outcome of the ASIC case would impact mortgage holders. He points out that the crypto Earner product offered a yield, whereas in the current context, Bitcoin is being used as collateral for a loan, a practice covered by the credit license. "Because we are talking about quite a different product, it’s unlikely," he said regarding ramifications for mortgage holders. "Regardless of the High Court’s outcome — it’s not going to have any bearing on this particular product as far as I can see."

Exploring Alternatives to Direct Bitcoin Mortgages

While Bitcoin mortgages present an exciting new avenue, it's also worth looking at other options, especially given the potentially higher interest rates associated with crypto-backed loans. Mortgage broker Chris Dodson, director of Mortgages Plus, acknowledges the innovation but also points out that Block Earner's rates and fees are significantly higher than typical. "That’s really aggressive. It seems those fees are double your main street bank or even your second or third tier lenders," Dodson remarked.

He notes that similar products exist for borrowers who need help scraping together a deposit but prefer not to risk their Bitcoin directly. For example, the OwnHome Deposit Boost Loan assists with the 20% deposit, then partners with a standard mortgage provider for the rest of the loan. Dodson explains, "You can put down a loan with 2% of the deposit, and they will back the other 18% with the interest rate of about 12% to 13%. So [it’s] similar." This offers a comparable solution for those struggling with a deposit, but without the direct exposure of their crypto to margin calls and potential liquidation.

The Ultimate Trade-Off: Property Security vs. Bitcoin Volatility

Perhaps the most comforting aspect of structured Bitcoin-backed deposits, as offered by some lenders, is the clear distinction of risk. James Coombs succinctly puts it: "There is no contagion risk to your property." He elaborates that with Block Earner, only the deposit component of the loan is secured by Bitcoin. This means your risk is centered on losing your Bitcoin collateral, not the actual property title itself. It’s an important distinction that provides a layer of security to the homebuyer.

For Cliff, this gamble is one he’s clearly willing to take. He humorously notes, "The amount I borrowed off them is more than what they [Bitcoin] cost me." This perspective underlines his belief that even in a worst-case scenario, where "the stuff hits the fan," he wouldn't be financially worse off than when he initially started accumulating his Bitcoin. Yet, his gaze is firmly fixed on the best-case scenario. Cliff hopes to pay off his properties as the value of his Bitcoin continues its upward trajectory. He points to historical trends: in December 2019, an average home in Australia cost around 84 Bitcoin. Today, that same home requires just 6 Bitcoin. That’s a staggering decrease in Bitcoin terms, showcasing the power of long-term crypto appreciation. "If the LTV comes right down and I only have to sell 10% or 20% of my Bitcoin to clear it up," Cliff muses, "I may decide to do that one day. We’re not at that point now, but who knows in the next cycle or two?" His story is a testament to the bold, calculated risks some are taking to blend the world of decentralized digital wealth with tangible real estate.

FAQ

  • What is a Bitcoin mortgage? A Bitcoin mortgage allows you to use your Bitcoin holdings as collateral to secure a loan for purchasing a home, rather than selling your crypto or relying solely on traditional assets.
  • What are the main risks of a Bitcoin mortgage? Key risks include high interest rates, margin calls if Bitcoin's price drops significantly, leading to potential automatic liquidation of your collateral, and the inherent volatility of the cryptocurrency market.
  • Do traditional banks accept Bitcoin as collateral for a mortgage? Generally, no. Traditional banks typically ignore cryptocurrency portfolios when assessing mortgage eligibility, focusing instead on traditional assets like savings and stocks. However, some US agencies consider Bitcoin as part of a borrower's reserves, and in Australia, an ETF can serve as collateral for high-value properties.

Conclusion

So, is the concept of a Bitcoin mortgage a stroke of genius or a recipe for disaster? As we've seen through Cliff's experiences and the broader market offerings, it’s a bit of both. It presents an incredible opportunity for crypto holders to unlock the value of their digital assets for significant real-world purchases like homes, without sacrificing the potential for future gains. The ability to buy property today and pay it off with a smaller portion of appreciated Bitcoin tomorrow is a compelling vision. However, this innovative path is fraught with genuine risks, from steep interest rates to the ever-present threat of margin calls and automatic liquidation during market downturns. Traditional financial institutions are slowly catching up, but crypto-backed loans remain a niche solution for a specific demographic. Ultimately, while the idea of leveraging Bitcoin for property is undeniably clever, the "insane" part comes down to an individual's risk tolerance and their conviction in the long-term trajectory of their digital assets. It’s a bold move, but for those like Cliff, it’s a calculated one that’s paying off, allowing them to enjoy the fruits of their crypto wealth in tangible ways.

إرسال تعليق